Getting Fit: The Lean vs Shredded Debate

  • By: Dave Moffat
  • Date: July 14, 2023
Lean vs Shredded

In the world of fitness, we often encounter terms like ‘lean’ and ‘shredded’. These words are not just fancy jargon; they represent distinct fitness goals with different implications for your workout regimen and diet.

When we speak about a ‘lean’ physique, we’re referring to a fit body, with a moderate amount of muscle mass and a low percentage of body fat. This look is healthy and athletic, with a toned appearance that indicates physical fitness without excessive muscle definition.

On the other hand, ‘shredded’ is a term that originates from the bodybuilding community. It refers to an extremely low level of body fat where muscles are highly defined and separated, hence the term ‘shredded’. Professional bodybuilders or fitness enthusiasts who aim for an extremely muscular physique frequently pursue this look.

Understanding the difference between ‘lean’ and ‘shredded’ is crucial for anyone setting fitness goals. These terms define the kinds of workout routines, dietary requirements, and lifestyle changes needed to achieve the desired results.

By having a clear understanding of what each term means, you can set realistic goals, make informed decisions about your fitness journey, and track your progress effectively.

Let’s delve deeper into these two fitness states and help you determine which one aligns with your personal goals.

Lean vs shredded Comparison Table

Sure, here’s a comparison table between being lean and being shredded:

Body Fat PercentageTypically around 10-15% for men, and 20-25% for women.Typically under 10% for men, and under 20% for women.
Muscle DefinitionSome muscle definition, particularly in good lighting or specific poses.High muscle definition, visible at all times regardless of lighting or pose.
LifestyleGenerally maintainable with a balanced diet and regular exercise.Requires a strict diet and intense exercise regimen, often difficult to maintain long-term.
Health ImpactGenerally healthy if achieved through balanced nutrition and exercise.Can be healthy in the short term for specific goals (like bodybuilding competitions), but maintaining extremely low body fat levels long-term may have negative health impacts.
Physical PerformanceGood balance of strength, endurance, and agility.May have high strength and muscular endurance, but overall performance can be impacted by extreme dieting necessary to achieve this state.
AppearanceFit and athletic.Extremely fit, almost “sculpted” look, with prominent muscle striations.

Understanding ‘Lean’

When we talk about a ‘lean’ physique in the fitness world, we’re referring to a body that is fit and toned, with a good balance of muscle mass and a comparatively low level of body fat. A lean body isn’t just about appearance; it’s also a marker of good health and physical fitness.

Characteristics of a lean body include visible muscle definition (though not as pronounced as in a ‘shredded’ body), a flat or slightly defined stomach, and a generally firm and fit appearance. It’s the look that you might associate with athletes who need a mix of strength, speed, and endurance for their sport.

Being lean comes with numerous health and fitness benefits. Lower body fat percentages are associated with lower risks of heart disease, diabetes, and certain types of cancer. On the fitness front, having a lean body often means improved athletic performance, better mobility, and increased energy levels.

Achieving a lean body is typically a result of following a balanced diet and maintaining a consistent exercise routine. This includes consuming nutrient-dense foods that are high in protein and fiber but lower in fats and sugars, and engaging in regular physical activity that combines strength training to build muscle with cardio exercises to burn fat.

Remember, the key to getting lean is not just about losing weight, but rather losing fat while preserving or even increasing muscle mass. This journey towards leanness requires dedication, patience, and a holistic approach to health and fitness.

Understanding ‘Shredded’

The term ‘shredded’ in fitness parlance describes a body that has extremely low levels of body fat, resulting in highly defined and separated muscles. It’s like the body has been ‘shredded’, revealing every muscle fiber and contour. This is the kind of physique you often see in professional bodybuilders or fitness models.

A shredded body is characterized by intense muscle definition, visible striations, and vascularity. It’s not just about having a flat stomach; it’s about showing off a six-pack (or even an eight-pack) and having every single muscle group, from your deltoids to your calves, clearly defined.

While being shredded can be a sign of extreme physical conditioning, it’s important to note that it also comes with potential health risks. Achieving such low levels of body fat often requires strict dieting and intensive training, which can put a strain on the body. It may lead to hormonal imbalances, impact mental health, and even compromise immune function if not managed carefully.

Getting shredded typically involves rigorous workout routines, often with a focus on high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and heavy weightlifting to build muscle mass.

Diet plays a crucial role too, with a strict regimen usually focused on high protein intake, low carbs, and careful management of calorie intake and timing. It’s not uncommon for those pursuing a shredded physique to also use supplements to support muscle recovery and growth.

Remember, achieving a shredded look is not for everyone, and it requires a significant commitment of time, energy, and discipline. It’s always important to approach such a goal with a balanced perspective, considering both the aesthetic desires and the potential impact on overall health.

The 10 Key Differences Between ‘Lean’ and ‘Shredded’

In the realm of fitness, ‘lean’ and ‘shredded’ are terms that define specific body goals. Although they might seem similar at first glance, they represent different body compositions, training routines, diets, and even lifestyles.

Here are the 10 key differences between being ‘lean’ and ‘shredded’:

  • Body Fat Percentage: A lean body typically has a lower-than-average body fat percentage but is within a healthy range. In contrast, a shredded physique aims for an extremely low body fat percentage to maximize muscle definition.
  • Muscle Definition: While both lean and shredded bodies display muscle definition, a shredded body takes it up a notch with more pronounced muscle separation and visible striations.
  • Diet: Maintaining a lean physique calls for a balanced diet that includes ample protein, carbohydrates, and healthy fats. Achieving a shredded look, however, usually requires a stricter diet with high protein, low carbs, and careful calorie management.
  • Workout Intensity: Regular exercise is essential for both, but the journey to a shredded physique typically involves more intensive workouts, such as heavy weightlifting and high-intensity interval training (HIIT).
  • Lifestyle: A lean body allows for a more flexible lifestyle, whereas a shredded physique often demands significant discipline and commitment, impacting various aspects of your life.
  • Health Risks: Both states promote physical fitness, but striving for a shredded look can potentially lead to health risks like hormonal imbalances and weakened immune function if not managed properly.
  • Maintenance: Generally, a lean body is easier to maintain over the long term. In contrast, maintaining a shredded physique often requires continuous, intense training and strict dieting.
  • Performance: Lean individuals often enjoy a balance of strength, speed, and endurance, making this state ideal for many sports. Shredded individuals, however, may have more strength and muscular endurance but less overall endurance due to their extremely low body fat.
  • Aesthetics: A lean body looks fit and toned, while a shredded body is highly muscular and chiseled, often resembling the physique of competitive bodybuilders.
  • Supplement Use: While supplements can be used by both lean and shredded individuals, those aiming for a shredded look might rely more heavily on them to support muscle recovery and growth.

Choosing Between Lean and Shredded

Understanding the Differences

Before we dive into the factors that can influence your decision, it’s essential to understand what defines a lean and shredded body. A lean body typically has a healthy but lower-than-average body fat percentage and moderate muscle definition. In contrast, a shredded body has an extremely low body fat percentage, allowing for highly pronounced muscle definition.

Personal Fitness Goals

Your personal fitness goals play a crucial role in determining whether a lean or shredded body is right for you. If you’re looking for a fit and toned appearance without needing to commit to an intensive workout regimen or a strict diet, a lean body might be your ideal goal. However, if you aim to achieve a highly muscular and chiseled physique, similar to what you’d see in competitive bodybuilding, you might aspire to become shredded.

Lifestyle Preferences

Consider your lifestyle preferences. Maintaining a shredded physique requires significant discipline, including adhering to a strict diet and intense exercise regimen. If you prefer a more flexible lifestyle that allows for occasional indulgences and moderate exercise, aiming for a lean body could be a more suitable choice.

Health Considerations

It’s critical to factor in your health when deciding between a lean and shredded body. While both promote physical fitness, striving for a shredded look can potentially lead to health risks, such as hormonal imbalances and weakened immune function, if not managed properly. Therefore, always consult with a healthcare professional before undertaking any drastic changes to your lifestyle, diet, or exercise routine.

Setting Realistic Goals

Remember, fitness is a journey, not a destination. It’s important to set realistic goals and celebrate small victories along the way. Whether you aim for a lean or shredded body, always prioritize your health and well-being.


In summary, the journey toward achieving a lean or shredded physique is unique for everyone and depends significantly on personal fitness goals, lifestyle preferences, and health considerations.

A lean body, characterized by a healthy but lower-than-average body fat percentage and moderate muscle definition, offers a fit and toned appearance and a relatively flexible lifestyle.

On the other hand, a shredded body, which has a very low body fat percentage and clearly defined muscles, calls for more discipline and commitment while providing a muscular and chiseled aesthetic.

Remember that there’s no ‘one-size-fits-all’ in fitness. Whether you choose to aim for a lean or shredded physique, it’s essential to make that decision based on what suits your individual needs and goals best. Prioritize your health and well-being, set realistic goals, and consult with healthcare professionals as needed.

Ultimately, the choice between getting lean and getting shredded is yours to make. Whichever path you choose, embrace it wholeheartedly, celebrate your progress, and enjoy the journey toward becoming the best version of yourself. Here’s to your health and fitness success!

+ posts

Hi, I'm Dave Moffat the founder and Chief Editor of and certified International Personal Trainer and Certified Nutritionist. My passion has always been bodybuilding but with 15 years' experience in weight loss programs too, it's hard not to mention all that when you're working at your fitness level fullest (I hope). When Im not in the gym or spending time away from my family i often think about what advice would help others achieve theirs goals just like these inspired mine.